Marty Stumpf

7 Apr 2022

â€¢

4 min read

This is the fourth of a series of articles that illustrates *functional programming* (FP) concepts. As you go through these articles with code examples in Haskell (a very popular FP language), you gain the grounding for picking up any FP language quickly. Why should you care about FP? See this post.

In the last post, we learned about **the foldable typeclass**, which provides the `foldr`

method. In this post, we'll learn what this method is with an example.

As mentioned in earlier posts, we can treat recursions as separate higher order functions known as recursion schemes. One type of recursion scheme is ** catamorphisms** (or

**Because knowing how to use recursion schemes improves your coding ability!** Consider this exercise: finding the minimum element of a list. In Haskell, without using fold, we would compare the elements of the list a one by one, keeping the minimum of the element, until we reach the end of the list. For example (interested readers can also see the OCaml version):

```
findMinInner :: Ord a => [a] -> a -> a
findMinInner [] curMin = curMin
findMinInner (hd : tl) curMin =
if hd < curMin
then findMinInner tl hd
else findMinInner tl curMin
findMin :: Ord a => [a] -> Maybe a
findMin [] = Nothing
findMin (hd:tl) = Just (findMinInner tl hd)
```

Using catamorphisms, we can find the minimum for an `Int`

list in two lines:

```
findMinFold :: [Int] -> Int
findMinFold l = foldr (\x y -> if x < y then x else y) maxBound l
```

Or, using the function `min`

in the prelude to replace the anonymous function and eta-reducing `l`

:

```
findMinFold :: [Int] -> Int
findMinFold = foldr min maxBound
```

**Catamorphisms dramatically reduce the amount of code because foldr does exactly what we want it to do for us: recurse down each element of the list.**

`Maybe`

type`findMin`

returns a `Maybe a`

. The `Maybe a`

type is used when a type can be `Nothing`

. It either returns `Nothing`

or the value. In this case, when the input list is empty, the minimum element is nothing. Running the code in GHCi gives:

```
*Main> findMin [9,2,3,1]
Just 1
*Main> findMin []
Nothing
```

Using `Maybe`

is not strictly necessary, Haskell's prelude (standard library) includes the `minimum`

function which throws an exception when an empty list is the input:

```
*Main> minimum []
*** Exception: Prelude.minimum: empty list
*Main> minimum [4,5,6,7,8]
4
```

`findMinFold`

, on the other hand, returns the base case when the input list is empty.

Going back to the above example, whatâ€™s going on in that one line?

First, let us look at `findMinFold`

's type from GHCi:

```
Prelude> :t findMinFold
findMinFold :: (Foldable t, Ord b, Bounded b) => t b -> b
```

`findMinFold`

takes a foldable type `b`

and returns a result of type `b`

. More specifically, it takes a `[Int]`

and returns an `Int`

.

We invoke `foldr`

in `findMinFold`

, which has the following type signature:

```
*Main> :t foldr
foldr :: Foldable t => (a -> b -> b) -> b -> t a -> b
```

That is, `foldr`

takes 3 inputs:

- A
*function*that takes two arguments, one of type`a`

and one of type`b`

, and returns a result of type`b`

. - An input of type
`b`

. - An input of foldable type
`a`

.

In `findMinFold`

, we've given `foldr`

2 inputs. The first is the function `min`

, of type:

```
Prelude> :t min
min :: Ord a => a -> a -> a
```

`min`

happens to have the second input type the same as the first, but bear in mind that it doesn't have to be as an input function to `foldr`

!

The second input is `maxBound`

, of type:

```
Prelude> :t maxBound
maxBound :: Bounded a => a
```

`Int`

is an instance of the [`Bounded`

](https://hackage.haskell.org/package/base-4.15.0.0/docs/Prelude.html# t:Bounded) typeclass. In `findMinFold`

, `maxBound`

is thus of type `Int`

. Note that `Integer`

and `Float`

are not bounded!

`foldr`

recurses the function with the earlier result as an input. In this example, `foldr`

does the following:

- When the list is empty, it returns the
`maxBound`

:

`fold_left min max_int [] => maxBound`

- When the list has one element, it returns the
`min`

of`maxBound`

and the element:

`foldr min maxBound [e1] => min e1 maxBound`

- When the list has two elements,
`min`

takes the result of`(min e2 maxBound)`

as an input, and compare it with`e1`

:

`foldr min [e1,e2] maxBound => min e1 (min e2 maxBound)`

- When the array has three elements, min takes the result of
`(min e3 maxBound)`

as an input to compare with`e2`

, the result of which is then compared to`e1`

:

`foldr min maxBound [e1,e2,e3] => min e1 (min e2 (min e3 maxBound))`

and so on...

We can generalize it to any function `f`

, with `z`

as the starting case and `x`

as the list input, the result is as in the [prelude](https://hackage.haskell.org/package/base-4.15.0.0/docs/Prelude.html# v:foldr) with `f`

as an infix operator:

```
foldr f z [x1, x2, ..., xn] == x1 `f` (x2 `f` ... (xn `f` z)...)
```

`foldl`

works similarly, except that the list elements are the first input to the function, and the brackets are to the left:

```
foldl f z [x1, x2, ..., xn] == (...((z `f` x1) `f` x2) `f`...) `f` xn
```

You can see from the above example that to find the minimum element of a list, we can use `foldr`

or `foldl`

, naturally with the `min`

function as the function input. But how do we choose the base case input?

The base case is what fold returns on an empty list input. When the input to `findMinFold`

is an empty list, the base case is returned. As you can see from GHCi, the maximum `Int`

on my system is `9223372036854775807`

:

```
*Main> findMinFold []
9223372036854775807
```

Other examples are:

```
-- adding 0 and x returns x
sum :: (Foldable t, Num a) => t a -> a
sum = foldr (+) 0
-- multiplying 1 and x returns x
product :: (Foldable t, Num a) => t a -> a
product = foldr (*) 1
```

Because the base case to `foldr`

is only there to safe guard an empty input, when you can be sure that the input is not empty, the base case would not be necessary! Haskell provides such option. Weâ€™ll see this in the next post, along with more examples of folds!

Did you like this article?

Marty Stumpf

Software engineer. Loves FP Haskell Coq Agda PLT. Always learning. Prior: Economist. Vegan, WOC in solidarity with POC.

See other articles by Marty

hello@works-hub.com

Ground Floor, Verse Building, 18 Brunswick Place, London, N1 6DZ

108 E 16th Street, New York, NY 10003

Join over 111,000 others and get access to exclusive content, job opportunities and more!